Entertainment TV The Masked Singer Shocker: Miss Monster Gets Eliminated as the First 3 Finalists Move Forward The remaining contestants will join the Super 9, who will face off later in the season By Dana Rose Falcone Dana Rose Falcone Dana Rose Falcone is a Staff Writer covering TV at PEOPLE. She has been working at PEOPLE for seven years. Dana Rose's work has previously appeared in Entertainment Weekly, Men's Fitness and Us Weekly. People Editorial Guidelines Published on February 12, 2020 09:06PM EST On Wednesday’s Masked Singer, the first group of disguised celebs got narrowed down to the three contestants who will move on to the finals later this season. The Valentine’s Day-themed episode opened up with a group number by the remaining four competitors — Kangaroo, Miss Monster, Turtle and White Tiger — singing “Rock and Roll All Night” by Kiss. Then each singer took the stage solo, preceded by a clue package that featured hints from the celebs’ loved ones. After giving their third performances of the season, the costumed stars presented one of the panelists with a Valentine that offered an additional club. The Masked Singer: Who’s Been Revealed So Far? Jenny McCarthy, Ken Jeong, Nicole Scherzinger, Robin Thicke and guest judge Leah Remini made their guesses, and at the end of the episode, they voted with the studio audience on their favorite performance. The contestant with the lowest amount of votes packed their bags and missed out on a chance to go to the finals. Despite being presumed to be a legendary singer by the panelists, Miss Monster earned the least love on the Valentine’s Day installment and had to take off her furry pink mask. Right before host Nick Cannon helped Miss Monster out of her adorable costume, Thicke and Scherzinger hypothesized “Ain’t Nobody” singer Chaka Khan could be underneath — and they were right. Miss Monster; Chaka Khan. Michael Becker / FOX; Frazer Harrison/Getty “I’ve just got to say, I have studied your voice so much. I’m so deeply inspired by you,” Scherzinger told the 10-time Grammy winner, 66, after her identity was revealed. Khan joins Lil Wayne (Robot) and Drew Carey (Llama) in this season’s eliminated contestant pool so far, meaning Kangaroo, Turtle and White Tiger will form the Super 9 with the top three singers from Groups B and C. Scroll down for how the performances broke down during this week’s Group A playoffs. Turtle Turtle. Michael Becker / FOX Clues: football field; favorite high school teacher, Miss S., who was his 9th grade biology instructor; Alpha and Omega; Seoul, South Korea Song: “There’s Nothing Holdin’ Me Back” by Shawn Mendes Panelists’ guesses: Hunter Hayes, Nick Lachey, Jaden Smith Valentine’s Day clue: To Nicole – “I’ll never forget the morning we spent together. It was turtle-y awesome.” Miss Monster Michael Becker / FOX Clues: pizza; white socks; a black and white teddy bear with a green bow; “I get to prove that true art comes from within.”; “Miss Monster, oh she’s my spiritual mom,” says her hairstylist.; “Miss Monster has been through a lot and she hasn’t always been seen in the press for who she really is. She’s all about spreading love.” Song: “You Don’t Own Me” by Lesley Gore Panelists’ guesses: Gloria Gaynor, Queen Latifah, Mary Wilson Valentine’s Day clue: To Robin – “I only have eye for you. We even had a rendezvous in Sin City.” RELATED VIDEO: ‘The Masked Singer’ Fans Think Jordyn Woods Is the Kangaroo: ‘I’ll Put Money on It Kangaroo Kangaroo. Michael Becker / FOX Clues: has a brother one year younger than her; plants; a model airplane; Her brother calls her “a drama queen in her teenage years.”; “When tragedy hit our family, she was the glue that held us all together.”; “Her grace under pressure and her ability to rise above the haters is always something I’ve admired.” Song: “Diamonds” by Rihanna Panelists’ guesses: Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, Lindsay Lohan, Jordin Sparks Valentine’s Day clue: To Leah – “We’ve sat at the same table and your courage has inspired me.” The Masked Singer Season 3 Costumes Revealed! Meet Banana, Llama, Robot and More White Tiger White Tiger. Michael Becker / FOX Clues: Historic Route 66 sign; a landline phone off the hook; unwrapped butter; a foam finger with No. 1; a quarter; “I knew going into this signing competition I wasn’t going to be the best singer.”; “I’ve always known how to work a crowd.”; His freshman year college roommate says, “When he commits to something, he doesn’t stop ’til he wins.” Song: “We Will Rock You” by Queen Panelists’ guesses: Fabio, Rob Gronkowski, Joe Manganiello Valentine’s Day clue: To Jenny – “I’m wild about you! But I know your husband will appreciate this card even more. The Masked Singer airs Wednesdays (8 p.m. ET) on Fox.