Here's how you can navigate constructive criticism from your boss.
Receiving constructive criticism from your boss can be a pivotal moment in your career development. It's a chance to gain valuable insights into your performance and areas for improvement. While it might be tempting to respond defensively, embracing this feedback can lead to significant personal and professional growth. As a career development coach, I've seen firsthand how handling criticism effectively can transform challenges into stepping stones for success. So, when your boss offers feedback, view it as an opportunity to enhance your skills and advance in your career.
-
Hanh Luong, ICF ACCHey young women, it’s time to Break Your Limiting Beliefs and just SHINE YOUR WAY
-
Manshi LowI help mid-careers sort out thoughts on careers 🚀 | Fresh perspective on your future 🎯 | MIT Engineer turned…
-
Lara MorganI help people build careers they love, through leveraging their strengths & desires; aligning their goals, building…
When your boss provides constructive criticism, the first step is to embrace it with an open mind. Understand that this feedback is not a personal attack but a professional assessment aimed at helping you grow. Listen actively and resist the urge to interrupt or justify your actions. By accepting criticism graciously, you demonstrate professionalism and a willingness to learn, which are key traits for career advancement. Remember, your boss's perspective can offer valuable insights that you might have overlooked, so use this as a chance to see your work through a different lens.
-
Feedback that stings often comes out of the blue. If you start to feel agitated or upset, grab a moment. To go to the restroom, to get a refill, to check the printer. That gives you separation to clear your head before you continue the conversation with your manager. An unproductive thing to do is to build a wall of defensiveness when this could be the one of the best learning opportunities for your career. Don't waste it on spur-of-the-moment defensiveness like I did.
-
The most remarkable supervisors offer feedback because they genuinely want to witness your growth. They deliver it in a manner that inspires and motivates. Embrace their constructive criticism as a personalized roadmap for your growth journey. Consider their insights as crucial milestones guiding you towards both personal and professional development. If you find yourself with a less supportive supervisor, seek additional perspectives and prioritize feedback that aligns with your goals. Genuine support and mentorship should steer your growth journey, even if it means seeking it elsewhere.
-
After listening actively to your supervisor's feedback, recap what you heard, e.g., "I hear you saying that abc did not go well because of xyz, and I need to make a change. Did I understand that correctly?" Following their feedback, thank them, let them know you will take this back to think about it/ and you will let them know what your plans are at your next meeting. It's important to create space between feedback and our response. This allows for thoughtful reflection on what to accept or change, and what information, if any, to share with our supervisor.
After receiving feedback, take time to reflect on what was said. Process the information away from the immediacy of the moment to fully understand the points raised. This reflection allows you to separate emotions from facts and to identify the core areas for improvement. Consider writing down the feedback to clarify your thoughts and to create a tangible reference for future action. Reflection is not about dwelling on negatives but about strategizing for positive change and recognizing patterns that may need adjustment in your work behavior.
-
It's crucial to approach feedback with a willingness to grow. But, reflecting on the boundaries of responsibility is equally important, especially in environments where unrealistic corporate standards take a toll on individuals. While constructive criticism can be valuable for professional development, it's essential to discern between what aspects of our performance we genuinely own and those that might be influenced by broader systemic issues within the organization. Sometimes, despite our best efforts, certain expectations can be unattainable or even detrimental to our well-being. Reflecting deeply can help us maintain a healthy perspective and focus on areas where we have agency and control. BTW, I'm a counselor specializing in burnout!
If any aspect of the feedback is unclear, don't hesitate to ask your boss for clarification. Seeking further information shows you're engaged in the process and committed to making meaningful changes. It also ensures you fully understand the expectations and how to meet them. Frame your questions positively and constructively, focusing on how you can improve rather than challenging the feedback itself. This dialogue can also help strengthen your relationship with your boss by demonstrating your proactive approach to personal development.
-
Don't be afraid to ask questions to your boss so you can understand the feedback more deeply. Being curious will also show your boss that the feedback is important to you and that you want to improve. Asking for concrete examples will help you understand when and where these instances have occurred, so you can catch yourself in the moment next time: "Could you provide more specific examples or suggestions on how I can address the areas you mentioned?" Another great question to ask is "Can you suggest some strategies or resources that could help me develop in these areas?"
-
Seeking clarification and asking questions are key to understanding performance expectations from your boss. It shows initiative and ensures alignment, leading to better outcomes. Embrace constructive criticism as an opportunity for growth by actively engaging in dialogue and seeking clarity.
With a clear understanding of the feedback, create an action plan for improvement. Set specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goals that address the areas highlighted by your boss. This structured approach ensures that you have concrete steps to follow and allows for tracking progress over time. Share this plan with your boss to show your commitment to change and to receive additional guidance or resources that might be available to assist you in your development.
-
By now, everybody knows about SMART goals, but it's worth highlighting the proactive step of sharing your plan with your supervisor. This action signals your commitment to growth and development, and by actively communicating your plan, you demonstrate a proactive approach to addressing areas for improvement.
Putting your action plan into practice is where the real work begins. Start making the necessary changes immediately, integrating new behaviors or strategies into your daily routine. Stay consistent and patient, as change takes time and effort. Keep a record of your progress and any new outcomes resulting from the changes you've implemented. This documentation can be useful for future evaluations or discussions with your boss about your development.
Finally, seek ongoing feedback to gauge how well you're implementing the changes and to make any necessary adjustments. Regular check-ins with your boss can provide you with a sense of how you're progressing and reaffirm your commitment to continuous improvement. This proactive approach not only helps you stay on track but also fosters a culture of open communication and ongoing professional development within your team.
-
3 steps in 4 seconds that I used to navigate my “critical” manager: 1. Acknowledge the information from what he/she said - 2 seconds 2. Detach the feeling or “critical” vibe from her and remind myself that: There must be some reasons made this “fire”, not just me :) - 2 seconds 3. Thanks her for telling you what she thought (instead of keep it in her mind and interpret the problem herself) - 1 second
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Employee RelationsWhat do you do if your supervisor gives you constructive criticism?
-
Global Talent AcquisitionHere's how you can handle constructive criticism in the workplace.
-
CommunicationHere's how you can effectively utilize feedback from your superiors to advance your career.
-
Job Search StrategiesWhat do you do if you want feedback on your performance from your boss?