Green shoots evident for battling Ireland despite opening Six Nations defeat in France

France 38 Ireland 17

Ireland's Aoife Dalton comes up against Lina Queyroi of France

Sinéad Kissane at the Stade Marie-Marvingt, Le Mans

Ireland lost their first game of the Women’s Six Nations but there were some promising green shoots in their performance against France at the Stade Marie-Marvingt, Le Mans. Ireland conceded five tries but they scored two thanks to Aoife Wafer and Aoife Dalton in the final ten minutes. Considering Ireland have lost by an average margin of 39 points to France over the previous four games, this was an improved display especially in defence.

It was a nightmare start for Ireland with France scoring their first try after just 130 seconds. The home-side’s line-out maul is one their big weapons and they used it to devastating effect after two minutes with scrum-half Pauline Bourdon Sansus peeling off to score the first try of the 2024 Women’s Six Nations. It was a nervy start by Ireland but they settled and a penalty from Nicole Fowley in the 14th minute got Ireland on the scoreboard at 7-3.

Fowley certainly didn’t play like it was her first Six Nations game since 2019 with an effective and pragmatic kicking game. It was also Ireland’s defence that stood out in the first half with French attacking waves being halted or overturned as Ireland scrambled and soaked up the pressure. The work done by new defence coach Declan Danaher was translated onto the pitch by the players. They were dogged as they made 96 tackles in the first half to France’s 74.

There were bright moments. Number 8 Brittany Hogan made a brilliant break up the pitch after 23 minutes and followed it up with a minute later with a brilliant tackle on Nassira Konde. While the French were having problems of their own at the line-out, this was a major issue for Ireland with four lost line-outs in the first half.

For 25 minutes Ireland kept the scoreboard at 7-3 until France got their second try eight minutes before the break. After a brilliant reverse pass from Sansus, Marine Menager ran a great line and sidestep to score. The conversion and penalty from Lina Queyroi helped France to a 17-3 half-time lead.

There was a change of outhalf for Ireland at the start of the second half as Dannah O’Brien replaced Fowley. Once again, France scored a try early in the half, this time from lock Madoussou Fall. France got their bonus point thanks to another powerful French rolling maul with hooker Agathe Sochat at the end of the move.

Squeezed between France’s fifth try scored by replacement Elisa Riffoneau were two Ireland tries. Ireland enjoyed some possession coming into the final 10 minutes and as they pounded the line, it was Wafer who dug her way over. It was Ireland’s first try against France in two years. O’Brien added the extras. And their hardwork paid off with a second try three minutes before full-time. A mistake by Lina Tuy on her own tryline saw Dalton quick to pounce and score Ireland’s second try. O’Brien added the conversion.

France won 38-17. Ireland need to fix their line-out and produce more attacking threat but it is a display that can be built on for their first home game of the championship against Italy at RDS on Sunday week. Perhaps then we can see more from a rising Ireland team.

Scorers – France: P Bourdon Sansus, M Menager, M Fall, A Sochat, E Riffonneau all trys, L Queyroi 4 cons, 1 pen, M Bourgeois con

Ireland: A Wafer, A Dalton try, D O’Brien 2 cons, N Fowley pen

France: E Boulard; K Arbey, N Konde, G Vernier, M Menager (M Bourgeois 44) L Queyroi (L Tuy 72), P Bourdon Sansus (A Chambon 61); A Deshayes (A Mwayembe 56) ,(A E Riffonneau 65), A Khalfaoui (C Joyeux 65), M Feleu (capt), M Fall (E Gros 51); C Escudero, G Hermet, R Menager

Reps: E Riffonneau, A Mwayembe, C Joyeux, K Zago, E Gros, A Chambon, L Tuy, M Bourgeois

Ireland: L Delany; K Corrigan (M Deely 67), E Higgins, A Dalton, B Parsons; N Fowley (D O'Brien 40) A Reilly (M Scuffil-McCabe 64); L Djougang, N Jones, C Haney (S McGrath 64); D Wall (F Tuite 56), H O'Connor; A Wafer, E McMahon (G Moore 51), B Hogan

Reps: S Delaney, N O'Dowd, S McGrath, F Tuite, G Moore, M Scuffil-McCabe, D O'Brien, M Deely

Referee: Kat Roche (USA)

FRA logo
FRA
38
:
17
IRL logo
Ireland
Dylan O'Connell
Full-time: The referee blows for full-time and France have beaten Ireland 38-17 in the Women's Six Nations Championship. 
Dylan O'Connell
78 mins: Dannah O'Sullivan makes no mistake with the conversion and she reduces the gap between the two teams to 21 points. 
Dylan O'Connell
77 mins: The game restarts with a handling error by France and Aoife Dalton snatches the ball. She grounds the ball and Ireland knock five points off Les Bleues lead. 
Dylan O'Connell
75 mins: The clock is now stopped as the TMO is reviewing the throw from the line-out. 
Dylan O'Connell
75 mins: France once again win their own line out. This time it is Elisa Riffonneau who gets in to score. 
Dylan O'Connell
75 mins: France win their own line-out at the corner and the maul is now pushing onto Ireland's goal-line. 
Dylan O'Connell
74 mins: France respond to that Ireland try by getting the ball onto Ireland's five meter line. 
Dylan O'Connell
72 mins: Dannah O'Brien kicks the ball over the bar from right in front of the posts and that is her first score of the 2023 Women's Six Nations Championship. 
Dylan O'Connell
74 mins:  Aoife Wafer burrows in to score Ireland's first try of the 2023 Women's Six Nations Championship. 
Dylan O'Connell
68 mins: Ireland are going through their best spell in possession in the second half and they now have the ball on France's five meter line. 
Dylan O'Connell
63 mins: The conversion is good and France extend their lead against Ireland with 17 minutes left to play. 
Dylan O'Connell
61 mins: France throw the ball to the back of the line-out and the maul pushes onto the goal-line. Agathe Sochat gets in to score a bonus point securing try for Les Bleues. 
Dylan O'Connell
59 mins: Ireland have the ball on the half-way line and Kelly Arbey forces a France turnover. 
Dylan O'Connell
55 mins: A TMO reviews means that the try scored by Kelly Arbey does not stand over a forward pass in the build up. 
Dylan O'Connell
55 mins: France get the ball back and catch Ireland out in transition. 18-year-old Kelly Arbey, carries the ball over the goal-line and she marks her first senior start with a try against Ireland. 
Dylan O'Connell
54 mins: A scrum is awarded to Ireland inside their own 22 and Aoibheann Reilly is getting ready to roll the ball in. 
Dylan O'Connell
50 mins: Grace Moore has replaced Edel McMahon. France now have the ball on Ireland's 22 meter line.